They Passed the Quiz. Can They Do the Job Safely?
Share
By Abbie Geigle
A new maintenance employee passes the ladder safety quiz on Monday. On Tuesday, a supervisor asks them to choose a ladder for a practice task.
The employee pulls one from storage and starts setting it up. They haven’t checked the side rails. One is cracked.
The supervisor stops the exercise and takes the ladder out of service. Then they walk through the inspection together.
The quiz showed that the employee understood the answers. Watching the practice task showed they needed help applying that knowledge. It also raised another question: How did a damaged ladder end up where someone could use it?
A passing score is a starting point
Quizzes can help employees review important information and show where they need more instruction. But answering a question correctly doesn’t always mean someone can safely perform the task.
An employee might know that equipment should be inspected, but not recognize a defect on the equipment they use. They might know they should report a hazard, but not know whom to contact on their shift.
That’s why employers should check more than course completion. Can employees explain the hazards, demonstrate the task and follow the procedures in their own workplace?
Watch a specific task
Choose a task and identify the steps that matter using your procedures, hazard assessments, manufacturer instructions and applicable requirements.
For a ladder task, a supervisor might observe whether the employee:
- Chooses the right ladder for the work.
- Inspects it and recognizes damage.
- Checks the work area for hazards.
- Sets it up according to the applicable instructions.
- Knows when to stop and ask for help.
Explain what you’re looking for, provide instruction and allow time to practice. Choose an evaluator who understands the task and meets any qualifications required by the applicable standard.
Keep the exercise controlled and stop if someone could be harmed. Never create a dangerous situation to see whether an employee catches it.
You can also ask, “What are you checking?” or “What would make you stop?” The answers may reveal questions the employee didn’t know to ask.
Give feedback they can use
“Be more careful” leaves an employee guessing. Instead, explain what you observed and practice the step together:
“You checked the feet and rungs, but you missed the side rails. A damaged rail can affect the ladder’s strength. Let’s go through the inspection again, and then you can show me on another ladder.”
After coaching, observe another demonstration. If the employee needs more practice, arrange it before assigning work they cannot yet perform safely. Document what was observed, the coaching provided and any follow-up needed, along with any records required by the applicable standard.
Look at the workplace, too
When an employee struggles with a task, ask what got in the way. Is the right equipment available? Do the written instructions match the job? Are employees given enough time to follow the procedure?
Training won’t fix a damaged ladder or make a confusing procedure clear. Those issues need attention, too.
General safety education provides a foundation, but employers must also address their workplace’s specific hazards and requirements. For example, employees covered by OSHA’s PPE training provision must demonstrate understanding of their training and the ability to use PPE properly before performing work requiring it. Check the standards and state requirements that apply to your operation.
Start with one task
This week, ask an employee to show you how they prepare for a task and explain when they would stop. Listen to their questions and follow up on what you find.
That short conversation may tell you something the quiz never could.
